.
Feedback

Big Brother Wants to Watch You, Bay Area!

Bay Area drivers could be required to install GPS-like odometers or other devices in their vehicles to pay for every mile driven.

In high school required reading included George Orwell"s Nineteen Eighty-Four. In the society that Orwell describes, everyone is under surveillance by the authorities. 

Since the publication of Nineteen Eighty-Four, the term "Big Brother" has become synonymous for government keeping an eye on you.  Today, I happily allow my phone to have an active GPS so my apps operate quickly providing the information I need local to me. I love, love, love my GPS system in my car as if it is stolen, my system can alert police to the location and even shut down the engine.

However a GPS used to track my mileage for the purpose of taxation is just too reminscent of Big Brother. I agree that we need more money for roads and public transportation. So raise the tax on fuel. It just seems a slippery slope indeed.

Last week Members of the Metropolitan Transportation Commission and the Association of Bay Area Governments approved going forward with further study of a possible Vehicle Miles Traveled tax for the nine county region. Drivers would be required to have GPS like devises to track for taxation.

Next I'll find out that all my Queen of Homemaking secrets are out because some disgruntled employee posted on the Internet exactly where I buy my particularly fresh produce. Or perhaps they will out me for being at the local yarn store too often. More likely, if anyone ever bothered to look, they would fall asleep from the sheer boredom of my travels.

But the probability that no one will pay attention to my meanderings isn't the point. The point is that they could if they so chose. 

So please butt out. Find a viable alternative that doesn't invade our privacy so blatantly. If the tax is to be based on miles then perhaps a semi annual tax based on mileage could be assessed at the time a smog certificate is done for the car. That way a third party is taking a look and registration withheld for non payment. Or perhaps they really do want to know where I get that produce...

 

Follow San Mateo Patch on Twitter | Like San Mateo Patch on Facebook | Sign up for the San Mateo Patch daily newsletter | Blog for San Mateo Patch



commuter July 23, 2012 at 12:52 pm
We need more money to maintain our roads. Gas taxes aren't nearly high enough, so most road maintenance and road construction is funded by sales taxes and income taxes. What is the advantage to taxing cars per mile instead of per gallon of gasoline? Seems to me that raising the gas tax is much simpler. How high would the gas tax need to be to cover all road construction and all road maintenance?
Anne Sammut July 23, 2012 at 08:29 pm
Why don't they try watching their budget instead of taxing us more? We all do!!
Seyaa August 21, 2012 at 06:20 am
Hi,
This is in deed new to me that such advancements are in vogue like that of GPS system. I think considering the negative aspect of it when it does not assure privacy in matters related to taxation, a betterment is certainly needed for all reasons. I stumbled on this article when I was reading <a href="http://www.malwareremoved.com/">malwareremoved.com</a>
Seyaa August 21, 2012 at 08:12 am
Hi,
This is in deed new to me that such advancements are in vogue like that of GPS system. I think considering the negative aspect of it when it does not assure privacy in matters related to taxation, a betterment is certainly needed for all reasons. I stumbled on this article when I was reading. <a href="http://www.malwareremoved.com/">click here</a>

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from San Mateo Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Pearl June 13, 2013 at 02:15 pm
This is a compete outrage!!! A 12.7% salary increase?!? A 100% increase in his car allowance?!?Read More I say get rid of Grasseli, Olbert, Collins and Clapper. Shame, shame, shame on them!!! They have sold the residents of San Carlos down the river!!! Remember this, San Carlos voters, the next time you go to the polls!!!
Paul Burnette and Grant Wood prepare to cut the ribbon with Deputy Mayor Ross
Kimberly Jennings May 29, 2013 at 10:14 am
How exciting to have some of the best orthotic specialists in the WORLD right here in our ownRead More backyard, and with such a commitment to patient care as their top priority! So glad to read this.
Marc Gottlieb June 2, 2013 at 03:53 pm
PS: Ideally, everybody will be able to sign up at the college website. But I have to acknowledgeRead More that some of the language may not be perfectly as clear as we'd like, especially if this is your first enrollment. So, if you need any assistance (or maybe aren't computer-savvy) the very nice Registrar Office people can assist you on 650/574-6165. Just tell them you want to sign up for Summer semester, Real Estate Practice 110 class, Course Reference number 54642 and that you'd like to complete the enrollment today. You'll like the class once we get you in! Thank you!
Marc Gottlieb June 2, 2013 at 06:25 pm
PS: Ideally, everybody will be able to sign up at the college website. But I have to acknowledgeRead More that some of the language may not be perfectly as clear as we'd like, especially if this is your first enrollment. So, if you need any assistance (or maybe aren't computer-savvy) the very nice Registrar Office people can assist you on 650/574-6165. Just tell them you want to sign up for Summer semester, Real Estate Practice 110 class, Course Reference number 54642 and that you'd like to complete the enrollment today. You'll like the class... and CSM... once we get you in! ALL WELCOME! Thank you!
Peter Radsliff May 27, 2013 at 08:56 pm
We have left the dog with the Peninsula Humane Society at 12 Airport Blvd. at Peninsula Ave.
imollyq May 30, 2013 at 09:55 pm
Among all the supporters isn't there one competent attorney who can get an injunction to keep theRead More rink from being destroyed and who can sue SPI Holding, and if necessary the City, to enforce the Master Plan Agreement? A toilet and an astro turf field are useless to ice skaters. I smell something rotten in the Mayor and the City Council's excuses. At least one skater must have a parent or family member who is an attorney with some sense of decency to do the work pro bono.
Claire Mack June 2, 2013 at 09:21 am
To close the ice rink is a crime. I had this conversation years ago with Peter Pau, the man whoRead More built it. We need places for children to recreate. When we send them to juvenile hall, we wring our hands and wonder why! No skate board parks in convenient places and now the skating rink. Why are our children the ones to sacrafice?